Whats the difference between from sklearn DecisionTreeClassifier and XGBoost?

Whats the difference between from sklearn DecisionTreeClassifier and XGBoost?
Photo by Jay Mantri / Unsplash


Both Decision Trees and XGBoost are machine learning algorithms used for classification and regression tasks, but they are fundamentally different in how they construct models and make predictions.

Let's break down some of the key terms and concepts you'd need to understand the article fully:

  1. Decision Trees: A type of supervised learning algorithm that is used for both classification and regression tasks. It breaks down a dataset into smaller subsets in a tree-like model of decisions.
  2. XGBoost: Short for "eXtreme Gradient Boosting," it is an optimized distributed gradient boosting library designed to be highly efficient, flexible, and portable.
  3. Classification and Regression Tasks: Types of supervised machine learning problems. Classification is about predicting a label, and regression is about predicting a quantity.
  4. Model Complexity: Refers to the number of features and parameters in the model, which influence how well the model can generalize from training data to unseen data.
  5. Binary Choices: Decisions that have only two options.
  6. Leaf Node: The terminal node of a decision tree where a decision is made.
  7. Interpretability: The ease with which a human can understand the rationale behind model decisions.
  8. Overfitting: A modeling error where a function fits the training data too closely but may not generalize well to new data.
  9. Generalization Capability: The ability of a machine learning model to adapt properly to new, previously unseen data, drawn from the same distribution as the one used to create the model.
  10. Deterministic Algorithm: An algorithm that will produce the same output when given the same input.
  11. Greedy Manner: A way of making the locally optimal choice at each stage with the hope of finding the global optimum.
  12. Objective Function: A function that the algorithm aims to minimize during the training process.
  13. Boosting: A method of converting weak learners into strong learners. In the context of machine learning, a weak learner typically refers to a model that does slightly better than random guessing.
  14. AdaBoost: Short for Adaptive Boosting, it's an algorithm that is used in conjunction with other types of algorithms to improve their performance.
  15. Parallelization: The act of doing multiple things at the same time during computational tasks.
  16. Ensemble Method: A technique that combines the predictions from multiple machine learning algorithms to make more accurate predictions than any individual model.
  17. Regularization: Techniques used to prevent overfitting by adding a penalty term to the objective function.
  18. L1 and L2 Regularization: L1 adds the absolute values of the parameters as a penalty term to the objective function. L2 adds the squares of the parameter values. Lasso is related to L1, and Ridge is related to L2.
  19. Stochastic: Randomly determined; introduced to add variability during the training process for better generalization.
  20. Gradient Boosting: A machine learning technique for regression and classification problems, which builds a model from weak learners in an iterative way.
  21. Hyperparameters: Parameters not learned from the training process but set prior to it, which influence the overall behavior of the model.
  22. Cluster: A group of computers networked together to improve performance, scalability, and availability.

Understanding these terms will give you a good foundation for grasping the differences between Decision Trees and XGBoost as described in the article.

Here are some of the key differences:

Decision Trees (DecisionTreeClassifier from scikit-learn)

  1. Model Complexity: A single decision tree is a simple model that makes decisions based on a series of binary choices. It asks a series of questions and traverses down the tree to arrive at a leaf node, which gives the prediction.
  2. Interpretability: Decision trees are highly interpretable and easy to visualize. You can trace the steps of the prediction by following the tree from the root to a leaf node.
  3. Prone to Overfitting: Without constraints (like tree depth), decision trees can fit the training data too closely, which reduces their generalization capability.
  4. Deterministic: Given the same data, a decision tree will always make the same prediction.
  5. Learning Method: Typically trained in a "greedy" manner, optimizing a single objective function.
  6. Boosting: Not built-in. If you want to use boosting with decision trees, you would have to implement it separately, e.g., using AdaBoost.
  7. Parallelization: Hard to parallelize as each node's decision depends on the entire dataset.

XGBoost

  1. Model Complexity: XGBoost builds an ensemble of decision trees to make more accurate and robust predictions. The "ensemble" nature makes it a complex model compared to a single decision tree.
  2. Interpretability: Being an ensemble of trees, XGBoost models are generally less interpretable than single decision trees.
  3. Regularization: XGBoost includes L1 (Lasso) and L2 (Ridge) regularization terms in its cost function to prevent overfitting.
  4. Stochastic: XGBoost introduces randomness during training for better generalization, through techniques like bagging of data.
  5. Learning Method: XGBoost uses gradient boosting, which is a more complex but usually more accurate learning method than the "greedy" method used in individual decision trees.
  6. Boosting: Built-in. XGBoost stands for "eXtreme Gradient Boosting", and as the name implies, boosting is an integral part of the algorithm.
  7. Parallelization: XGBoost is optimized for both computational speed and model performance; it can be parallelized across CPUs and even distributed across a cluster for larger datasets.
  8. Flexibility: XGBoost can handle missing values, supports various objective functions, and can be tweaked using several hyperparameters.

In summary, while decision trees are simple models that are interpretable and quick to train, XGBoost is a more complex, powerful, and flexible model optimized for performance and speed but often requires more computational resources and fine-tuning.